Undermining encrypted messaging will harm public confidence says BCS

By Ben Carey on 21 April, 2023

BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT based in Swindon, has warned against weakening encryption for secure messaging apps.

According to the organisation, the potential change in online safety legislation will damage public trust in technology, and it is vital that End-to-End Encryption (private messaging) is not undermined by scanning of personal communication.

The Online Safety Bill, which contains wide-ranging legislation that aims to regulate internet content to keep people safe, is currently being considered by the House of Lords.

The bill will give media regulator Ofcom powers to demand that such platforms identify and remove child abuse content, and refusal to comply could see companies face large fines.

WhatsApp, Signal and others have raised concerns about the bill, with some saying they would prefer to exit the UK market than attempt to comply. 

Rashik Parmar MBE, Chief Executive of BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT, said, “It’s the wrong time to weaken encryption when it is vital to [increase] public trust in the value of technology.

“Every genuine tech professional wants children to be safe online; but we need to guard the basic security that underpins everyone’s privacy.

“There is grave concern that the online safety bill’s requirements around identifying illegal content could break the principle of end-to-end encryption with the promise of a magical backdoor. Once a backdoor has been compromised, data and content protected by the encryption becomes accessible.

“Building confidence in technology is a global priority in 2023. A bill aimed at keeping us safe online should protect encrypted messaging.”